Why I Am Dead Gave Me Something Better Than a Platinum Trophy
In the current PlayStation 5 landscape, the chase for a Platinum Trophy is often the ultimate goal for completionists. But sometimes, a game offers a reward that resonates more than a digital icon on your profile. For I Am Dead, the quirky, supernatural puzzler, that 'something better' is a tangible, tongue-in-cheek badge of honor: the Master of Riddles certificate.
A Ghostly Tale of Shelmerston
If you haven't played it, I Am Dead puts you in the spectral shoes of Morris Lupton, the former curator of a museum on the charming, volcanic island of Shelmerston. After passing away, Morris reunites with his deceased pet dog, Sparky. The stakes are surprisingly high—you’re racing against an impending volcanic eruption that threatens your home, and the only way to stop it is to locate a new guardian for the island.
While the premise involves death and natural disasters, the game avoids being heavy-handed. It trades gloom for warmth, whimsy, and a distinct charm. The gameplay is straightforward: you navigate through stages, examining objects and people to piece together memories of the island’s departed inhabitants. While the loop can feel slightly repetitive, the ability to inspect items and view their cross-sections provides a satisfying tactile experience.
The Real Challenge: Beyond the Platinum
To secure the Platinum, you’ll need to go well beyond the main story. The trophy list encourages a deep dive into the optional content, specifically hunting for 'Grenkins'—small spirits cleverly hidden within objects—and tackling Mr. Whitstable’s riddles. These riddles are particularly demanding, tasking you with identifying specific objects within a limited timeframe. It’s the kind of challenge that forces you to truly learn the layout and details of every level, revealing secrets you’d likely miss on a casual playthrough.
However, the highlight isn't just the Platinum Trophy notification. It’s the sense of accomplishment that comes from completing Mr. Whitstable’s rigorous tasks. Earning the Master of Riddles certificate feels like a genuine reward for the time invested in mastering the game's mechanics. It’s a rare moment where a game’s optional challenge feels more meaningful than the standard trophy completion itself.
Whether you're hunting for that Platinum or just looking for a bittersweet, engaging puzzle experience, I Am Dead is well worth your time on PS5. Just don't be surprised if you find yourself valuing that Master of Riddles certificate just a little bit more than the final trophy on your list.